If you're remodeling a bathroom in your Seattle home, replacing your old tub is probably part of your project's scope. If long soaks aren’t really your thing and you prefer a quick, invigorating shower, you may be asking yourself: “Should I replace my bathtub with a walk-in shower?”
Should You Replace Your Bathtub with a Shower? What to Consider Before You Do
Traditionally, real estate experts advised against removing your tub, especially if you were planning on selling your home anytime soon. After all, a bathroom wasn’t considered "full" unless it had a tub and homes with only showers were often viewed as less desirable by potential buyers. Bathrooms with just showers are called three-quarters baths. You wouldn't want to reduce the number of full baths in your home, would you?
The New Rules of Tubs and Showers
Times are changing, and if you prefer the look of a nice walk-in shower to a tub, by all means, specify it in your bathroom remodel. And you don't have to worry about it hurting your home's resale value. Houselogic, a publication of REALTORS, studied the issue:
The American Institute of Architects says that the tub-less bathroom is growing in popularity. Its annual Home Design Trends Survey found that more than 60% of homeowners preferred a stall shower without a tub in 2013. Compare that to 49% in 2012, the first year they specifically surveyed about tub-less bathrooms.
There is one catch, however. If you're planning on converting a tub to a shower, be sure you leave at least one tub in your house.
Go ahead and convert your old tub or tub/shower combo into a cool, walk-in shower, as long as one other bathroom in your house has a tub for tasks such as bathing small children.
The Shower vs. Tub Debate: Which is Better?
People still can't agree on which is better and there is no universal answer. This decision depends on your lifestyle, household needs and resale goals.
Reasons to Choose a Shower:
- More accessible for aging in place
- Easier and quicker to clean
- Sleek, modern design
- Saves space in smaller bathrooms
Reasons to Keep a Tub:
- Better for bathing children
- Useful for resale, especially in family homes
- Ideal for soaking and relaxation
- Adds a sense of luxury to a primary suite
If you never use your bathtub and dream of a luxurious, spa-like walk-in shower, don’t hesitate to make the switch—just make sure at least one other bathroom in your home still has a tub.
At CRD Design Build, we specialize in bathroom remodels that match your lifestyle, aesthetic and long-term goals. Whether you’re remodeling for functionality, accessibility or style, our team can help you decide what works best for your home. Contact us today to explore your options and get started on your next remodel!
